jmtorres: Utena and Anthy kissing, Revolutionary Girl Utena. My prince has come. (femme)
jmtorres ([personal profile] jmtorres) wrote2009-12-13 04:04 am

mixed feelings

There's a patch of my scalp that's a little tender right now, because I was bleaching the hell out of my streak (I'd let the roots get out a couple of inches) to re-dye a new shade for the wedding. I'm only using 30 peroxide, not anything rougher and tougher and salon strength, so getting my hair bleached enough to take cool colors takes a few runs--the first go gets me from dark black-brown to vibrant orange; the second to a paler orange, around where I can drop a magenta or red on it; the third bleaching gets me to a light gold that can slide under violet, though I'd probably twitch at trying to get it under blue, because blue will green out on you. (Two or three more runs gets it to proper platinum, but I don't so much do that all at once--it's just what happens with the length of the streak when I'm working on the roots.) So all told I spent a cumulative two hours with bleach in my hair tonight, and yeah, my scalp is sore.

Beauty is pain, right? /irony

(In an ideal world I would just naturally have a white streak up front like Rogue or Sam Beckett, and when I felt like dyeing it an accent color to go with my dress and my mood as I periodically do, I wouldn't have to bleach it first.)

My mother likes my streak bleached but undyed; she says I look like a marbled cake with blonde and brown hair. I did that look for a while when I first got up the gumption to bleach the streak--and it took gumption; when I told my mother on the phone, because I was away at college at the time, my lead-up made her think I'd gotten a tattoo or something permanent, because I really thought she'd disapprove like crazy. Maybe that's why I didn't finish the job with the dye, then, and yeah, it felt unfinished, the bleaching's always just to make a canvas for the color. But I really did feel that my mother wouldn't get it, would make me feel guilty about it--not for doing something non-conformist with my hair, no. For using beauty products, for falling prey to societal pressure to do things that are bad to my body to try to look pretty.

I think I'm the wannabe punk child of a wannabe hippie flower child.

Growing up, I absorbed from my mother that: make-up is a waste of time and clogs your pores and by the way, lipstick is to make your mouth look like labia; leg and pit hair is natural and women in Europe don't shave it off, so why should we; that mustache ain't going anywhere no matter what you do to it (this was probably my mother's longest hold out in the vanity department, she was bleaching her mustache long after she'd called it quits on a lot of other regular beauty work); heels will screw up your feet and back; Barbie is not a natural shape and not one to aspire to--I nearly added it's okay to be fat, but that one didn't quite stick, because my mother did pressure me to diet with her all the time. By the way, we're both still fat. I think she still tries to lose weight. Eventually I got her to leave me out of it. My stance is I don't want to work specifically to be thin; if I lose weight because I'm working my ass off, then yay, but I'm not going out of my way for it. This seems to me to be the natural extension of everything else she taught me about rejecting society's urges to prettify, tempered with an acknowledgement that all false images of what health is aside, I am actually fatter than is healthy.

So there's all of that. The anti-pretty, where pretty is defined by glossy magazines and Hollywood movies. Except that on some level, I do still want to be pretty, even though I know how false all of that is. The first time I acted in a theatre show in college and the director showed us how to put on make-up, not street make-up, pancake make-up, but you know, with cheekbone shaping rouge and eyeliner to make your eyes big and dark, everything exaggerated for stage--I looked in the mirror and thought, "I'm pretty," and I hadn't known that was possible, I hadn't ever thought of myself as pretty before.

I didn't start wearing street make-up. I don't do that for everyday life. There are occasions when I'll do measures of it for performance, and I don't necessarily mean stage performance, because not all performances are the official kind. Part of my rebellion and part of my queerness is that I don't do that performance for men--the most frequent occasions are Club Vivid at Vividcon, which has an overwhelming majority of female attendees. But pretty isn't who I am on a day to day basis, and though pretty still gives me a little surge of guilty pleasure, I am content to look like what I actually look like here in real life.

Except for the hair.

Here's another thing about my hair: getting my hair braided, especially braided in some fancy, intricate way by someone else, is a guilty pleasure for me. I don't know why; braiding doesn't fall under the same stigma of pretty in most cases for me--I braided my mother's hair when I was a kid, and it's not load-the-chemicals-on alteration of self that she taught me to rail against. But there despite that sanction, I still feel like a pretty, pretty princess when someone does my hair, and feeling like a pretty, pretty princess is a guilty feeling for me. Ironically, it's an act of defiance against my (personal/familial instead of societal) norms to ask for it.

And then there's the bleach and the dye. It has been eight years since the first time I bleached my streak in; I have been inconsistent about maintaining it (see also: a couple of inches of roots) but it's been part of my self-image ever since. I guess that's an act of defiance against my personal/familial norms too, but one specifically designed to be outside the conventional definition of pretty too: unnatural colors, and just the one streak, not the whole head of hair. But it makes me hugely uncomfortable on a philosophical level that I have to buy into artificial beauty products to do it. I have this tender patch on my scalp right now, reminding me that everything my mother taught me to resist in the idea of hurting yourself to look different than you are because society thinks you should. There's a push-pull of how I want to look and how I look without alteration and how I want not to look specifically because the world says I should want to look that way. It's hard for me to sort out. I can't quite solve it; the contradiction is rooted somewhere primal in the construction of my personality.

I have a whole hell of a lot of identity tied up in my hair. The other day at work I said something about being butch, regarding my badassery at moving boxes of books--mostly in jest, because the butch/femme binary is not quite synonymous with my issues and not really how I think of myself. My boss said I'd need to cut my hair off if I wanted to look butch and my automatic answer was No. I also said that short hair is not a requirement for being butch and it's an attitude more than a look and that my boss was being reductionist and on some level I believe all of that and on some other level, that was all rationalization for that instant answer, No. No, my hair's not going anywhere. There's too much me there.

But a me I need to manipulate, to alter. Why is that? What is it about me that I need to look different from what I am?
nic: (Default)

[personal profile] nic 2009-12-13 01:37 pm (UTC)(link)
Very interesting post, and quite a bit resonated for me.
Growing up, I absorbed from my mother that....

I learned all of that from my mother too. She was on a perpetual diet, but never lost the weight. I now have a weight obsession because of it.

I have a whole hell of a lot of identity tied up in my hair.

And yes, THIS. My hair is not my natural hair but it means so much to me, my identity, that I will not listen to anyone's suggestions concerning it.
kymellin: chaos star, white on black (Sandman - Death)

[personal profile] kymellin 2009-12-13 03:03 pm (UTC)(link)
Having my hair braided by another person is an AMAZING feeling!!! I don't ever ask for it - having someone ask to touch my hair makes me feel pretty in a way that nothing else does (even if it is a grandma in the local JoAnn Fabrics). That someone wishes to transform it into one of the many ways it can dress up...wow.

I also have most of my identity in my hair - it is the main aspect of my physical self; the rest of my identity is in what I can do and how well I do it (I try not to have too much of my identity in my kid, but that is a hard thing - I have had over half my life shaped by his existence, but he's an individual with his own identity).

Just as I can dress up or down, my hair is transformative - and my concept of myself is also different depending on the situation. I've only messed with the color once (every time I'm about to, someone comments positively on my greying head, but I have a natural streak in front - it's amazing how many people like that). It kills me that I have to get mine cut every so often due to arthritis issues, but even that is an extension of who I am.

Just as clothes or make-up tells others something about you, hair also fills that function. My opinion is that you should enjoy playing with how others see you, wear your rebellion or conformity as you see fit, and have some fun. It's not being a slave to how others see you - it's presenting yourself however you wish to be seen. Not a stereotype, not an expectation, but an individual.
sasha_feather: Retro-style poster of skier on pluto.   (Default)

[personal profile] sasha_feather 2009-12-13 03:16 pm (UTC)(link)
I too learned a lot of this from my mom, the idea of being able to reject the culture's obsessions with beauty if I wanted to, which I did.

I have short hair now and probably always will, but there is something about having my hair touched and braided that calls back to my mom brushing it and putting it into French braids that makes me feel very loved and cared for.

Interesting post.
sasha_feather: "subversive" in rainbow colors (subversive)

[personal profile] sasha_feather 2009-12-13 07:05 pm (UTC)(link)
This post got me thinking about how "feeling pretty" can be feeling valued, cared for, appreciated, nurtured; rather than simply visually appealing. I think it a lot to do with confidence too.

And yeah, it can be hard to speak up and say, oh hey, I don't shave, I don't like to wear make up, I don't diet, etc, in part because one can be mocked for it, and also because it can be an implied judgment on those who do. I don't know what people's reactions are going to be, and women can be very policing of each others' appearances and bodies. One thing I've struggled with a bit is getting over that feeling of judgment-- think "Legally Blonde"-- that people who are into that stuff are not necessarily better or worse than me. I've struggled with this concept a lot, as part of femininity, as part of queer identity, and examined it in a way I suspect a lot of people (ie straight men) don't always have to.
branchandroot: oak against sky (Default)

[personal profile] branchandroot 2009-12-13 06:06 pm (UTC)(link)
*nodnod* I got a whole lot of that from my mother, too. And the thing about choosing one or two things to do anyway; for me it's tweezing my eyebrows. It kind of feels like... my claim on being a thinking animal? That I won't change how I look because of What They Say but I'll change the things I want to change because I can make myself what I want to be.
pineapplechild: HELLO!, says the giant squid, wait why are you running away (Default)

[personal profile] pineapplechild 2010-03-06 02:42 am (UTC)(link)
Hah, hair is weird for me. I've had long hair-- really long, not just this to the shoulders stuff, down almost to my butt-- since I was in first grade as a kid. I generally wear it tightly braided or tightly bunned, out of my way. Generally, when I wear it down, everyone who knows me has a small moment of "why don't you wear it down more, it's so pretty~" and they feel the need to touch it.

I love having my hair touched. By people I know/trust a lot. Otherwise it creeps me out. Casual hair touching is a major line for me-- from friend to reallygood!friend, from person I'm flirting with/friends with to person I'm dating, for two examples. (Or back. I'm currently working on being friends with an ex, and the first thing I did when we stopped dating was touching his hair. Eh. That sounds weird out of context.)

I've seriously considered cutting my hair off all of twice, in the wake (both times) of serious emotional upheaval.

Wee, hair.

I've always struggled with this tendency to dress-- not unlike myself, but myself-as-acceptable in various social circles. I've joked that I don't have a coherent look, I have about six different people's wardrobes in my closet. And it kinda bugs me, when I think about it.