jmtorres: From Lady Gaga's Bad Romance music video; the peach-haired, wide-eyed iteration (Default)
jmtorres ([personal profile] jmtorres) wrote2009-11-13 12:58 am

Soon, there will be no walls left

Okay, right, the lack of female fans was atrocious, I was seriously expecting more crossplayers and somebody to be genderswapped Dean and Sam and stuff, the lack was disturbing, and it was particularly awful that the ghost actress was a Hooters waitress instead of a fangirl there fangirling, but I do wonder, um.

Was the multiplicity of Deans and Sams, and particularly the elevation of, a recognition that multiple interpretations are possible and valid? I got the feeling that maybe the gay Dean and Sam cosplayers were Kripke going, "Okay, your wincest Dean and Sam are not how I think of Dean and Sam but if it works for you..." Was that? Possibly intended as a conciliatory message?

(Though why Girl Dean and Girl Sam and Drag King Dean and Drag King Sam could not have been part of that multiplicity is beyond me...)
brokenbacktango: Image from the Star Trek original series episode "Operation Annihilate!" (STXI: Captain Robau)

[personal profile] brokenbacktango 2009-11-14 06:57 pm (UTC)(link)
You're really not kidding when you say "Soon, there will be no walls left."

Other than Becky, there was one pair of crossplayers (I wasn't even aware of this term before now, I love it) in the foreground at the beginning of the scene that revealed the featured fanboys to be a gay couple--that was it for female fans. I'm both disappointed and relieved that there weren't more fangirls in this episode. First and foremost this was a comedic episode so any more interpretations of female fans would have been crazy stereotypes like all the other fan characters. Becky met that quota and then some. The fact that it's reinforcing the notion that most fans active in fandom are men annoys me, however that is something prevalent in ALL media portrayals of fandom, not just Supernatural. Methinks that's a network problem more than a Kripke and Co problem.

I read your recent interpretation of the episode and I really enjoyed it. I'm afraid I don't have a lot to contribute to it since I'm still blurry-brained from sleep but I really appreciated reading it. Thank you :)
brokenbacktango: Image from the Star Trek original series episode "Operation Annihilate!" (STXI: USS Kelvin)

[personal profile] brokenbacktango 2009-11-14 07:52 pm (UTC)(link)
No, unfortunately they were just extras background performers whose characters were being interviewed by a cop. I squealed like a little girl when I saw them, though :)